Sydney M. Williams
burrowingintobooks.blogspot.com
Burrowing into Books
“American Dialogue: The Founders and Us”, Joseph J.
Ellis
May 27, 2019
“The study of
history is an ongoing conversation
between past and present from which we
all have much to learn.”
Joseph
J. Ellis (1943-)
American
Dialogue: The Founders and Us
The study of history allows us
to better understand – not to idolize or condemn, not to excuse or justify –
the past. It provides us the ability to debate today’s issues, many of which
have roots in years long ago.
As Joseph Ellis explains, the U.S. was founded on paradoxes: A
Declaration of Independence was declared; a Constitution was drafted and
confirmed; a government of three co-equal branches was formed. Yet slavery
would be the future for African Americans; the lands of Native American Indians
would be confiscated, and women would not receive the vote until 1920. These
are the inconsistencies that consume Professor Ellis, and which make necessary
a dialogue; for, as he sums up, “…we rise
or fall together, as a single people.” He accomplishes this in four parts:
Thomas Jefferson and race; John Adams and economic equality; James Madison and the
judiciary, and George Washington and foreign policy. In a final chapter
entitled “Leadership,” he reminds us that in 1788 four million newly minted
Americans had a choice for President between George Washington and John Adams.
Two hundred and twenty-eight years later, three hundred and fifteen million
Americans had a choice between Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump!
Professor Ellis recently retired as Ford Foundation Chair of history at
Mount Holyoke College. He is a winner of the Pulitzer Prize (Founding
Brothers: The Revolutionary Generation) and the National Book Award (American
Sphinx: The Character of Thomas Jefferson). He has authored a dozen biographies
and histories about our founding years.
In this book he engages four of the founders, their thoughts at the
time and their impact today. Jefferson: “While his views on race were
horrific, his words on liberty and freedom are magnificent. We should know both
and not let the former destroy the latter.” Adams: “Reason holds the
helm, while passions are the gales.” While we strive for equality, “inequality
is the natural condition of mankind.” Madison: During debates as to whether
sovereignty should remain with the states or reside in the federal government:
“…argument itself became the abiding solution, and ambiguity the great asset.”
He was the principal author of the Constitution and, with Alexander Hamilton,
the voice behind the Federalist Papers. Washington: “The myth, the monument
and the mythology are so mixed together they can never be disentangled.” He
was the architect of foreign policy. “He saw Europe as the past and the
American frontier as the future.”
The American founding was a “collective
enterprise,” with founders harboring different beliefs as to the meaning of
the American Revolution and for what sort of government should evolve. “This political and psychological diversity
enhanced creativity by generating a dynamic chemistry that surfaced in the arguments
whenever a major crisis materialized. Diversity made dialogue unavoidable.”
Given today’s focus on identity, there is irony in the diversity that emerged
from founders who were all white, heterosexual (as far as we know) males of
English heritage. Their diversity came to fruition in debate, formed from
opinions derived from reading and were based on how and where they lived. It
was from this furnace of invisible differences and visible sameness that our
nation was born.
“Conflict is part of the human condition and can never be eliminated.
Neither can the desire for power and the tendency to abuse it,” wrote
Wilfred McClay in his history of the U.S., Land of Hope: An Invitation to
the Great American Story. Yet, by almost any measure the results of
the Founders have been a resounding success, as Joseph Ellis tells us. For
someone born in the developing world there is no other country where most would
choose to live. Part of that is geographic. We are abundant in natural
resources. We have no aggressive neighbors. As well, we have no landed
aristocracy. We are merit based. Ultimate authority is embedded in our
citizens. We are peopled with those from myriad lands and cultures. To travel
to this country from afar required (and requires) aspiration, a willingness to
work hard and self-reliance. Our system of government has been tried, notably
during the Civil War and during the 1960s. We, the people, have prevailed, and
we should again today, as divisiveness again consumes our nation. Professor
Ellis quotes Alexis de Tocqueville on America: “I am full of apprehension and hope.” These thought-provoking essays provide reason for on-going dialogues
and continued debate. For it is only when arguments cease and all seems
settled, when silence reigns, that we should worry.
Like us today, the Founders
weighed the possible versus the ideal – “the distinction between a realist and an
idealist, a skeptic and a believer.” Joseph Ellis recognizes the individual flaws
of the founders, but he also acknowledges the extraordinary success of what
they achieved – the nation and government they built. One does not have to
agree with all opinions expressed to get the value of the message conveyed by
Professor Ellis – an intelligent and necessary dialogue is only possible with
knowledge of the issues and resolutions that were confronted and decided upon by
those who founded this nation two hundred and fifty years ago. This is a book
that should be read by all who care about the political and cultural chasm that
divide us today.
Comments
Post a Comment